Ten cigar subscription clubs compared on cigars per box, price per stick and who does the picking, including the biggest names like Privada, Cigars International and JR, plus a look inside our November 2026 box.
Every cigar subscription promises "premium, hand-picked cigars." That phrase tells you almost nothing. What separates one club from another is simpler: how many cigars you get, what each one actually costs you, who is doing the picking, and for us customer service.
We took a look at all the most popular subscription boxes.
Full disclosure: we run one of these clubs. So we'll tell you plainly where the others beat us on price, and where we think we earn the difference. All cigars ship to adults 21 and over.
How we compared them
We looked at four things for each club: cigars per box, monthly price, price per stick, and how the cigars get chosen. Some clubs pull from a big retailer's warehouse. Others buy boutique and allocated releases directly. Prices below come from each club's own site or recent coverage, checked in November 2026. Clubs change prices often, so confirm before you sign up.
The clubs, side by side
Best for big-name brands
Holt's Cigar of the Month Club. Five cigars a month for about $30 to $35, shipped free, roughly $6 to $7 a stick. Holt's has sold cigars out of Philadelphia since 1898, and its boxes lean on household names like Arturo Fuente, Ashton, Padrón and Oliva. (mostly the core lines)
Best for the lowest price per stick
Cigars International Cigar of the Month Club. Four cigars for $21.99 a month, or eight for $34.99 on the Double Decker plan, shipped free with a Boveda pack. That's about $4.50 to $5.50 a stick, the lowest on this list, from one of the biggest online cigar retailers in the country.
Best for big-retailer reliability
JR Cigars Cigar of the Month Club. Five cigars for $30.95 a month, about $6 a stick, or six for JR Plus members. It's run by JR Cigar, one of the oldest and largest cigar retailers in the US.
Best for volume
Smoke Inn Cigar of the Month. Five cigars for $34.95 or ten for $59.95, about $6 to $7 a stick. A good fit if you smoke most days and want variety over rarity.
Best for picking your spend
Luxury Cigar Club. Six tiers, from Core at $18.99 for three cigars up to Platinum at $50.95 and Sapphire at $69.99 for five or more, topped by the Diamond tier at $150 a month for five to seven of their rarest cigars. Some boxes include LCC-exclusive blends.
Best for gifting
Rare Cigar Club. Four small-batch cigars for $61.95 a month with free shipping, about $15.50 a stick. Prepaid gift memberships are easy to set up.
The biggest name in rare
Privada Cigar Club. Three cigars a month for $28.99, about $10 a stick. Founded in Orlando in 2017 by Brian Desind, it bills itself as the largest cigar subscription in America, with more than 18,000 monthly subscribers. The focus is rare, aged and limited cigars, many made just for its members.
Best for club-only blends
Tobacco Tactical Cigar Club. Five cigars for $55 a month, or $300 for six months prepaid, shipped free in the US. That's about $10 to $11 a stick. The boxes focus on small-batch blends, special projects and limited releases, many sold only to club members.
Best for beginners
CigarClub. A short taste quiz sets your box, with three, five or ten cigars from about $30 to $85 a month. Useful if you don't yet know what you like.
Best for boutique and allocated
Unicorn Hunters Club. Five cigars a month for $99, or $891 for the year. Not the cheapest on this list, and we don't try to be. Every box is built around boutique, limited and hard-to-find releases, some UHC™ exclusives. Members also get two Pegasus™ Packs a year at no extra cost, each one containing five unicorns usually worth $150 or more. Counting those, it works out to about $17 a stick on the monthly plan, or under $13 on the annual plan.
What you actually get at each price
Under about $8 a stick, you're mostly getting good, widely available cigars at a discount. That's real value if you smoke a lot. Between $10 and $15 a stick, boutique brands start showing up regularly. Past $15, you're paying for cigars you'd struggle to find on a shelf: small production runs, allocated releases, anniversary blends or club exclusives.
The question isn't which club is cheapest. It's which price band matches how you smoke.
Inside our November 2026 box
Here's a real example of what Hunter's Reserve ships. November brought back a Tatuaje Halloween Monster, a World Cup limited edition, a revived Dominican cult blend, a Connecticut from El Septimo's Emperor Collection and one of our favorite lanceros, the EGM.
Tatuaje Monster JasonConnecticut Broadleaf · Nicaragua · My FatherPete Johnson's Halloween Monster series brings Jason back for 2026, in coffin-shaped boxes of 13.→
OZ Family World Cup 2026 Limited EditionToro · 6 × 50 · My Father CigarsMade for the 2026 World Cup: a San Andrés wrapper over tobaccos from five nations, only 2,026 boxes of 10.→
El Septimo King Sargon ConnecticutChurchill · Connecticut · Costa RicaFrom the Emperor Collection, named for Sargon of Akkad, the first emperor in recorded history. Smooth and creamy.→
Chogüí Dos77Robusto Extra · 5½ × 50 · Dominican RepublicA 2015 cult blend named for a lost box, No. 277, now back with a sun-grown Dominican Corojo wrapper.→
EGM EncantosLancero · 7½ × 39 · Dominican puroCibao Valley tobacco rested two years. Cedar, cream and gentle spice, 90 points from Cigar Journal.→ Get next month's box
Which one should you pick?
If you want the most cigars for the least money, Cigars International's Double Decker is hard to beat. If you smoke several cigars a week and want familiar brands, Holt's, JR or Smoke Inn are solid picks. If you want to control your spend and move up over time, Luxury Cigar Club's tiers make that easy. If you're buying a gift, Rare Cigar Club is simple. If you want rare cigars at an entry price and don't mind three a month, Privada is the biggest name in that lane. If you want blends you can't buy anywhere else, Tobacco Tactical's club-only releases are worth a look. If you're new and want guidance, CigarClub's quiz is a good start.
If you've smoked the big names and you're hunting for the cigars that never make it to the shelf, that's the box we build.
Hunter's Reserve Membership
$99/month · or $891 for the year
Five hand-picked cigars every month, each one scored against our 100-Point Review System. Every box comes with the Hunt Report, and two Pegasus™ Packs a year are included: five unicorns each, usually worth $150 or more. That brings the total per stick from $13-$17 depending on monthly or annual plans.
Explore Hunter's ReserveFrequently asked questions
What is the best cigar subscription box?
It depends on how you smoke. For the most cigars per dollar, Cigars International, Holt's, JR and Smoke Inn run about $4.50 to $7 a stick. For boutique and allocated releases, expect to pay $13 to $20 a stick at clubs like Rare Cigar Club, Luxury Cigar Club's upper tiers, or Unicorn Hunters Club.
What is the largest cigar subscription?
Few clubs publish member counts. Privada Cigar Club says it has more than 18,000 monthly subscribers and calls itself the largest in America. CigarClub and the big retailer clubs from Cigars International and JR Cigar are also among the most widely used.
How much does a cigar subscription cost?
Most run from about $19 to $150 a month. Entry boxes carry three to five cigars. Premium boxes usually carry four or five, at a higher price per stick.
How many cigars come in a monthly cigar box?
Usually three to five. Some clubs, like Cigars International, Smoke Inn and CigarClub, offer an eight- or ten-cigar option.
Is a cigar subscription worth it?
It's worth it if you smoke at least a few cigars a month and want someone else doing the sourcing. It's less worth it if you already know exactly what you like and can buy it locally.
Can I give a cigar subscription as a gift?
Yes. Most clubs, including ours, let you buy a membership for someone else. The recipient must be 21 or older.
Jack Ambriz, Founder of Unicorn Hunters Club